Homepage Knowledge Choosing an ERP System: Key Factors and Criteria

ERP

Choosing an ERP System: Key Factors and Criteria

@mindbox

Zespół Mindbox

7 minutes

“You reap what you sow” is an apt expression for the situation businesses face when choosing an ERP system. Whether this is a first implementation or involves replacing an old system with a new one, the level of difficulty is similar. The complexity of ERP solutions and their impact on virtually every aspect of an organization’s operations make the right choice critical from every perspective. After all, the purpose of an ERP system is to integrate all of a company’s business processes.

What does the ideal ERP system look like?

Ideals have a firm place in algebra, but real life is not quite so accommodating. That does not mean we cannot dream. An ideal ERP system would:

  1. Provide all the functionality currently needed to support the company’s most important processes, without unnecessary extras that would rarely be used[ii].
  2. Have a clear, ergonomic and straightforward user interface that requires minimal training to master.
  3. Require no major investment in existing IT infrastructure, such as servers, licenses and new peripherals.
  4. Work equally efficiently locally, on-premises, and in the cloud.
  5. Make its functionality available on any end-user device, including desktop computers, laptops, tablets and phones, and do so securely, protecting company data against unauthorized access.
  6. Allow the production version to go live in months rather than years.
  7. Avoid disrupting the company during implementation or requiring an excessively large group of its best specialists to be assigned to the project.
  8. Have low operating, modification, support and regulatory compliance costs.
  9. Be reliable, efficient and scalable, with functionality that can easily be extended and adapted to changing business processes.
  10. Provide documentation, interfaces and tools for integration with other specialized systems supporting manufacturing processes, such as CAD/CAM software, CNC systems, software robots, industrial automation, sensors and actuators, or even government e-services such as e-invoicing and Poland’s Central Register and Information on Economic Activity (CEIDG).
  11. Avoid giving the board heart palpitations when the final implementation and launch price is announced.
  12. Strengthen the company’s competitive advantage in a visible, readily measurable way, generate significant savings, optimize processes and improve the operation of the entire organization.

Key factors to consider when choosing an ERP system for your company

In practical terms, the most important stage in the long and difficult process of choosing an ERP system appears to be a comprehensive assessment of how it handles the business processes that matter most to the company. These critical areas clearly reveal whether the solutions being compared can meet the company’s specific needs, how efficient and scalable they are, and whether they will make processes easier to manage. Examining the details closely is a great help in making the right decision.

After years of development, ERP systems offer very similar functionality. As a result, references from companies in the same industry with a similar profile and scale of operations are now decisive. They provide a degree of assurance that the chosen solution will prove its value again under similar organizational conditions.

A third, equally important factor is the experience and capabilities of the ERP implementation company. The same system, such as SAP, one of the leading ERP solutions, can be implemented successfully or become the source of a spectacular failure.

Ultimately, there must be clear evidence that the implementation will bring new energy and momentum to the business and deliver a high, measurable return on investment.

The total cost of ownership (TCO – Total Cost of Ownership) must also be included among the key selection criteria. The purchase price of licenses and the implementation cost are only part of the picture. The vendor’s pricing flexibility for support, modifications and regulatory compliance also matters. Only by comparing all costs over a period of, for example, ten years — the expected lifespan of an ERP system — can a particular solution be properly assessed.

The ERP software vendor matters

Around 50 different ERP systems are available in Poland. Choosing a particular ERP system means committing to its developer and supplier for many years, making the decision all the more significant. There are plenty of dilemmas here too. Is it worth investing in a cheaper solution from a vendor that is relatively new to the market? Should you consider only Polish companies because they understand local legal requirements better, or choose a system used worldwide? Will the vendor be able to support implementation teams? How long will you have to wait for additional functionality and modifications? The questions are endless, and finding the right balance is far from easy.

In practice, experience in a particular industry and customer references appear to carry the most weight. Although ERP is a single category of software, its vendors have their own specializations. Differences are evident in the size of the companies they serve, implementation costs and functional areas. Fortune 1000 companies, for example, are most often served by vendors such as SAP, Oracle, Microsoft Dynamics and Infor. Another large group consists of vendors offering comprehensive solutions for manufacturing and distribution companies, including Epicor with its Kinetic system, Plex, Sage and NetSuite. Finally, a third group consists of smaller vendors whose systems have more varied functionality. They tend to operate in local markets, with fewer implementations and smaller clients.

Is it therefore worth choosing a top-tier vendor? The answer is simple: sometimes, yes. However, that decision must be made with an understanding of the risks and confidence that the available functionality can be put to good use as the company grows.

The ability to test the ERP system

ERP testing, including automated testing, is a quality assurance process (QA – Quality Assurance) intended to ensure that an ERP system is correctly implemented and works properly before the full launch. Test results are crucial to the final decision. It is therefore essential to ensure that testing is possible in the first place and that test conditions resemble the production environment as closely as possible.

If the ERP software runs in a private, public or hybrid cloud, the service configuration must always be verified, along with report generation and display, and the operation of custom dashboards. Any source code modification made for a particular process or team may negatively affect performance or the functionality available to other users.

As a general rule, the following tests should be carried out:

  1. Functional testing to check whether the system works correctly and meets expectations for supporting business processes.
  2. Performance testing to assess communication between different systems and the speed of transaction processing under high data volumes. This makes it possible to check how the ERP system withstands critical loads.
  3. Integration testing to verify whether the ERP system can correctly integrate different processes, use APIs and work with other specialized software, peripherals and sensors that measure operating parameters. Integration tests should use typical scenarios from the daily work of the system’s prospective users.

ERP testing minimizes the overall risk of implementation failure, prevents unnecessary downtime in the production system, reduces the training time required and helps avoid employee frustration, all of which translates into measurable financial savings.

ERP system pricing: what should you consider?

Ideally, the price of an ERP system would be calculated as a percentage of the savings it generates. Life would be simpler. In practice, however, the final price depends on many factors. Some relate to the buyer’s existing IT infrastructure, others to how quickly users learn the system or the condition of historical business data, and others simply to the ERP system selected.

When estimating the total price of an ERP solution, the main factors to consider are:

  1. All licensing fees, covering not only the ERP system but also the necessary system software, servers, storage, databases and application servers.
  2. The number of system users and how this relates to licensing.
  3. The price of individual modules, so that the cost of unused or rarely used functions can be minimized.
  4. System hosting costs under different licensing models.
  5. The cost of necessary IT infrastructure upgrades, including expansion of server facilities.
  6. The time and cost involved in migrating historical data to the new system.
  7. Hourly rates for implementation team members, developers, consultants, analysts and other specialists.
  8. How modifications, additional functions, extensions and integration work are priced.
  9. The cost of testing, preparing test scenarios and providing the necessary infrastructure.
  10. Training costs.
  11. Support costs and response times in the event of a failure.
  12. The cost of updates, development and maintaining compliance with current legislation.

As you can see, there is no shortage of cost components, so it is hardly surprising that the final cost of implementing an ERP system can reach USD 8,200 per user. Fortunately, the profits and savings generated after implementation demonstrate that the investment is worthwhile.

@mindbox

Zespół Mindbox

Newsletter

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Newsletter (EN)